Reverse Mortgage Refinance: HECM-to-HECM and the Exit Refi

Refinancing a reverse mortgage means one of two distinct transactions. The first is a HECM-to-HECM refinance — replacing an existing reverse mortgage with a new reverse mortgage, governed by HUD's 5×5 test for borrower benefit (the new loan must produce additional principal limit equal to at least 5 times the closing costs, AND the new principal limit must be at least 5% higher than the existing balance; HUD Mortgagee Letter 2004-18 and Handbook 4000.1, Section II.B.10.b). The second is refinancing OUT of a reverse mortgage into a forward mortgage to end the balance growth and return to a conventional payment structure. Both transactions require HUD-approved counseling. This page covers both paths and when each makes sense.

Last reviewed 2026-05-20

What are the two kinds of reverse mortgage refinance?

The phrase "reverse mortgage refinance" gets used for two transactions that work in opposite directions.

HECM-to-HECM refinance keeps the borrower in a reverse mortgage. The new HECM pays off the existing HECM at closing; the borrower walks out with a higher principal limit (more available cash), a different rate structure, or an updated non-borrowing spouse status. The reverse-mortgage relationship continues; only the contract changes.

HECM-to-forward refinance ends the reverse mortgage. A new conventional or government-backed forward mortgage on the same home pays off the HECM at closing; the borrower returns to a monthly mortgage payment. The reverse mortgage relationship ends.

The two transactions serve different goals and run on different rules. The 5×5 test below applies only to the HECM-to-HECM path.

What is the 5×5 test for a HECM-to-HECM refinance?

HUD does not permit a HECM-to-HECM refinance for its own sake. The new loan must demonstrably benefit the borrower under the 5×5 test, established in HUD Mortgagee Letter 2004-18 and codified in HUD Handbook 4000.1 Section II.B.10.b:

1. The 5× closing cost test. The increase in the borrower's principal limit from the refinance must be at least 5 times the closing costs of the new loan. If a new HECM has $8,000 in closing costs, the principal limit on the new loan must be at least $40,000 higher than the balance being paid off.
2. The 5% increase test. The new principal limit must be at least 5% higher than the existing loan balance. A borrower with a $200,000 existing balance must qualify for at least $210,000 of new principal limit.

Both tests must pass. The borrower must net materially more available funds than the refi costs.

The common case where the 5×5 test passes: home values have risen substantially since the original HECM closed, the older borrower has aged into higher principal limit factors (PLFs grow with borrower age in HUD's lookup tables), or interest rates have fallen enough to push the PLF up. The combination produces a higher new principal limit; the 5× closing cost ratio and the 5% increase both clear; the refi is approved.

The case where it fails: a borrower wants to refinance after a modest home-value rise that does not justify the closing costs. The 5× test catches this and HUD declines the refinance.

A separate exception exists: a HECM-to-HECM refinance to add an eligible non-borrowing spouse (typically a younger spouse who was below the age floor at the original closing but now wishes to be protected by the eligible non-borrowing spouse rules) can be approved on protection grounds even where the 5×5 numbers are marginal (HUD Mortgagee Letter 2015-15). The counselor and lender document the protection rationale.

What are the closing costs and counseling for a HECM-to-HECM refinance?

A HECM-to-HECM refinance carries the same closing-cost categories as the original HECM (HUD Handbook 4000.1, Section II.B.10.b):

• Origination fee, capped by HUD at 2% of the first $200,000 of home value plus 1% of value above that, with a $2,500 minimum and $6,000 maximum.
• Upfront mortgage insurance premium at 2% of the maximum claim amount (the lesser of appraised value or the federal HECM lending limit).
• Standard third-party costs: appraisal, title insurance, recording, credit report, flood certification, and any state/local fees.
• HUD-approved counseling, required for every HECM-to-HECM refinance just as for an original HECM (HUD Mortgagee Letter 2014-12). Counseling typically costs $125 (waivable on income grounds) and is documented by a counselor's certificate.

The MIP is charged on the maximum claim amount of the new loan, but a MIP credit applies for the portion already paid on the existing loan (the upfront MIP is non-refundable on the original loan, but a refinance does not double-charge the full 2%; the credit reduces the new upfront MIP to the marginal amount).

How does refinancing out of a HECM into a forward mortgage work?

Refinancing out of a reverse mortgage replaces the HECM with a standard forward mortgage. The new loan pays off the HECM balance at closing; the borrower returns to a monthly payment of principal and interest; the reverse-mortgage relationship ends.

When this makes sense:

• The borrower's income, credit, and DTI now support a standard mortgage payment. A borrower who took out a HECM as a temporary cash-flow tool while between income sources may, when circumstances change, want to stop the balance growth and return to a conventional structure.
• An heir is buying out the loan to keep the home in the family. The heir qualifies for a forward mortgage in their own name on the same property; the proceeds retire the HECM; title transfers to the heir. This is the most common refinance-out scenario for families.
• The non-recourse cap no longer matters. A HECM is most valuable when the balance has compounded past the home's value and FHA insurance is covering the gap. A borrower with substantial remaining equity who wants to preserve it for an estate may prefer to end the HECM and switch to a forward loan.

The forward refinance underwrites like any forward mortgage: the borrower's income, credit, DTI, and the home's value drive approval. The HECM payoff figure (balance plus accrued interest, MIP, and servicing) comes from the servicer.

For the broader exit-decision frame — refi, family buyout, sale, or wait for a future maturity event — see how to get out of a reverse mortgage.

When is refinancing not the right move?

Three situations argue against a reverse mortgage refinance in either direction:

The 5×5 test fails. A HECM-to-HECM refi that does not produce 5× the closing costs in additional principal limit is not financially helpful; the closing costs eat the benefit. HUD's rule is doing the borrower a favor by blocking these.

The balance has already grown past the home's value. Refinancing out into a forward mortgage requires that the home appraise high enough to support the new loan, and the borrower must qualify for the payment. A borrower whose HECM balance is above the home's value is being protected by the non-recourse cap; refinancing into a forward loan would surrender that protection and impose a payment they may not be able to afford.

Short remaining tenure in the home. Refi closing costs amortize over the time the new loan is in place. A borrower planning to sell or move within a few years rarely recovers the closing costs through any refi benefit.

Run the calculator →

FAQ